两种蚊虫智能监测设备现场诱捕效果评价

Field evaluation oftrapping efficacy of two smart mosquito monitoring devices

  • 摘要:
    目的 比较蚊虫智能监测设备和蚊虫常规监测方法的现场捕蚊效果,评估蚊虫智能监测设备蚊种识别的准确性,为筛选出适合本地区的蚊虫智能监测识别技术及终端监测设备提供参考。
    方法 2025年5-10月在浙江省苍南县农村居民区开展了成蚊密度监测,监测方法包括智能监测仪器S和B进行24 h不间断连续监测,以及每周一次的诱蚊灯法、双层叠帐法与BG-Mosquitaire法的常规监测。 摘取智能监测仪器同一时段自动记录的监测数据与常规监测方法相比较,以评估蚊虫智能监测仪器的捕蚊效果及蚊种智能识别与计数的准确性。
    结果 在库蚊活动高峰时段,捕获致倦库蚊平均蚊密度分别是诱蚊灯7.85只/(灯·夜)、B蚊虫智能监测仪器1.27只/(灯·夜)、S蚊虫智能监测仪器0.23只/(灯·夜),均值两两比较显示差异均有统计学意义(均P<0.05),S和B智能监测仪器诱捕效果劣于诱蚊灯法;在伊蚊活动高峰时段,捕获白纹伊蚊平均蚊密度分别是BG-Mosquitaire法8.92只/(灯·h)、双层叠帐法3.65只/(帐·h),差异有统计学意义(U=190,P=0.006),两种蚊虫智能监测仪器均未捕获到白纹伊蚊,且不能反应季节消长情况,4种监测方法中BG-Mosquitaire法捕获白纹伊蚊效果最好。 此外,S和B智能监测仪器能够捕获当地主要蚊种即致倦库蚊以及白纹伊蚊并进行鉴定,但其他能鉴定蚊种种类有限,且存在蚊种鉴定误差率分别为27.50%、32.31%,差异无统计学差异(χ2=0.347,P>0.05)。
    结论 在农村居民区的生境下,S和B蚊虫智能监测仪器的对蚊虫诱捕效果与季节规律反映方面不及常规监测方法。 两种仪器均能采集到当地的主要蚊种并进行蚊种鉴定,但存在一定的误差率,且智能鉴定蚊种种类有限。 目前这两种蚊虫智能监测仪器在长期系统的调查或监测中尚不足以替代蚊虫常规监测方法。本研究为蚊虫智能监测设备的实际应用提供了参考,对提升蚊媒传染病的早期识别与应急响应能力具有重要意义。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective To compare the field mosquito capture efficacy between smart mosquito monitoring devices and routine monitoring methods, evaluate the accuracy of mosquito species identification by smrt monitoring devices, to guide the selection of appropriate local intelligent surveillance technologies and terminal equipment.
    Methods From May to October 2025, adult mosquito density monitoring was conducted in rural residential areas of Cangnan county. In the monitoring smart monitoring devices S and B was used for a 24-hour monitoring, and routine lamp trap, human-baited double net trap, and BG-Mosquitaire trap were used for weekly monitoring .The data recorded by the smart monitoring devices were compared with routine monitoring data during the same periods to evaluate the trapping efficacy of the smart devices and the accuracy of mosquito species identification and counting.
    Results In the peak hours of Culex quinquefasciatus activity, the average mosquito density of was 7.85 /night by using lamp trapping, 1.27/night by using the smart mosquito monitoring device B, and 0.23 /night by using the smart mosquito monitoring device S, the differences were significant (all P<0.05), the trapping efficacy of the smart mosquito monitoring devices S and B were lower to that of lamp trap. In peak hours of Aedes albopictus activity, the average mosquito density was 8.92 /h by using the BG-Mosquitaire trap, 3.65/h by using the Human-baited double net trap, the difference was significant (U=190, P=0.006), while the two smart mosquito monitoring devices captured no A. albopictus and failed to reflect seasonal fluctuations. In the four monitoring methods, the BG-Mosquitaire trap showed the highest efficacy in capturing A. albopictus. In addition, the smart mosquito monitoring devices S and B all could capture and identify the local major mosquito species, i.e. Culex quinquefasciatus and Aedes albopictus, However, their ability to identify other mosquito species was limited. The identification error rates of the smart devices S and B were 27.50% and 32.31%, respectively, the difference was not significant(χ2=0.347, P>0.05).
    Conclusion In rural residential areas, the smart mosquito monitoring devices S and B showed no better performance in mosquito trapping efficacy and seasonal pattern analysis compared with routine methods. While the both devices can identify predominant local mosquito species, although the error can occur and the species identified are limited power. The applications of these smart monitoring systems remain inadequate to replace routine methods in long-term systematic monitoring programs. This study results can be used as reference for the practical application of smart mosquito monitoring equipment, which is of great significance for improvement early detection of mosquito-borne infectious diseases and subsequent emergency response.

     

/

返回文章
返回